Franziska Knolle
PhD, Principal Researcher
Department of Neuroradiology, School of Medicine and Health
Technical University of Munich
Predictive processing accounts of psychosis propose that positive symptoms arise from disruptions in how the brain balances sensory evidence and prior beliefs. Overweighting of sensory signals at lower processing levels, possibly driven by increased dopamine activity, may lead to aberrant salience and delusion formation, whereas overweighting of high-level priors, potentially linked to altered glutamatergic signalling, may underlie hallucinations. Language processing is inherently predictive and therefore well-suited to investigate this potential imbalance. Previous studies have indicated that individuals with increased psychotic/schizotypal traits or frank psychosis show improved speech detection in noise, potentially due to stronger global prior beliefs. In a series of four experiments, we explore 1) whether schizotypal traits are associated with stronger priors during semantic language perception in noise; 2) whether levels of cortical glutamate explain a potential imbalance in prior weighting; and 3) whether schizotypal traits are generally associated with enhanced speech detection and, importantly, accurate content recognition in noise.
In experiment 1, 109 individuals assessed on schizotypal traits completed a predictive language task in which we simultaneously manipulated semantic predictability, sensory degradation, and surprisal to estimate the prior weight using a Bayesian belief updating model and potentially induce task-based hallucinations. In experiment 2, we replicated the findings of experiment 1 in 55 individuals with schizotypal traits but also measured MR spectroscopy to assess cortical levels of glutamate. In experiment 3 and 4, we investigated speech detection in noise without context in 90 individuals with schizotypal traits using signal detection theory. In experiment 3 speech detection was assessed by linearly increasing intelligibility of single words throughout one trial, while experiment 4 measured speech detection by presenting words in only randomly assigned intellegibility level in each trial. Participants indicated speech detection and, when possible, reported the perceived word, allowing for separate estimates of detection bias and objective recognition thresholds.
Results of experiment 1 and 2 showed that higher schizotypal-traits were associated with increased prior weighting, more task-based hallucinations, and altered cortical glutamate. This indicated that during sentence comprehension, individuals with increased schizotypal traits form overly strong semantic beliefs explaining increased task-based hallucinations. In experiment 3 and 4, schizotypal traits were linked to a reduced speech detection thresholds but not to improved word recognition. Lower thresholds for both speech and noise trials indicated a stronger bias to report speech rather than enhanced perceptual sensitivity.
These findings converge on a pattern in which individuals with higher schizotypal traits rely more on local prior information in predictive language contexts but show a decisional bias towards reporting speech under noisy conditions, without actual perceptual advantages. Such a response bias could make individuals more prone to impose meaning on ambiguous input, increasing the likelihood of unrealistic interpretations and thereby contributing to the emergence of positive symptoms.